Should You Get Separate Rims for Winter Tires? Pros, Costs & Benefits Explained

Do You Really Need Separate Rims for Winter Tires?

In Edmonton and other parts of Canada, winter tires are a must for navigating snowy and icy roads. As Canadians, we are no strangers to the semi-annual tire swap performed on our vehicles.

Most of us tend to switch between our all-season and winter tires on the same set of rims. In most cases, it’s the high cost that prevents motorists from considering an additional set of rims.

If you share the same set of rims between both sets of tires, you may want to consider acquiring an extra 4 rims specifically for your winter tires. Even though it may carry a large up front cost, having an extra set of rims for your winter tires is beneficial for your vehicle, your tires and, ultimately, your bank account.

The Advantages of Winter Rims

First and foremost, the upfront costs of additional rims will save you money in the long run. Most auto shops charge an additional fee to remove tires from the rim and place a different tire on the rim. When you have your winter tires placed on their own rims, you are only paying for the balancing and installation of the tires.

ou’ll also save money by avoiding the need to replace your rims later. When you use the same set of rims throughout the year, you run the risk of damage caused by snow, ice and salt. Also, having tires removed and placed onto the rim over and over will cause unnecessary wear and tear to the rims.

Alloy VS Steel Rims

When it comes to choosing a set of rims for your winter tires, you have a choice between steel and alloy rims. Cost-wise, steel rims are less expensive but alloy rims are available in a wide price range. Before you get caught up on sticker prices, consider which rim is more appropriate for your needs.

Do keep in mind that steel rims are the recommended choice for winter tires and winter driving.

Tire Pressure

They contract in size far less than alloy rims in cold temperatures. The more a rim contracts, the more inconsistent the tire pressure becomes.

Uneven tire pressure can lead to uneven traction and tire wear issues. Since the tires can wear to differing degrees, your vehicle may experience instability issues including bad traction and brake problems.

Style and Appearance

Alloy rims are more stylized than the functional appearance of a steel rim. However, many chrome finishes on alloy rims are not warrantied in the wintertime.

Alloy rims without fancy finishes do have the advantage of being more resistant to rust and corrosion caused by road salt.

Rust and Dents

Even though steel rims are prone to rust, they can be easily repaired and repainted. They are also easier to repair than alloy wheels when it comes to dents – which are more likely to happen during the winter season due to road conditions and potholes.

Rim Weight

Alloy rims are lightweight whereas steel rims are heavier and can cause decreased acceleration and poorer fuel efficiency.

This may be advantageous in the wintertime, however. Heavier rims help the tires grip more closely to snow and ice, making winter driving safer.

Tire Pressure and Performance in Cold Weather

Cold temperatures cause air pressure to drop naturally, and rims that contract significantly—like some alloys—can worsen that effect.

Inconsistent tire pressure leads to:

• Uneven tread wear
• Reduced traction
• Poor braking performance

On the other hand, steel rims maintain more stable tire pressure in extreme cold, making them a smarter choice for winter safety.

Style vs. Function: Which Matters More?

There’s no denying that alloy rims look more stylish than steel ones. But when winter hits, function should take priority.

Steel rims are built for durability and protection, while alloy rims are designed for aesthetics and performance. If you do choose alloy rims, opt for powder-coated or painted finishes to resist corrosion.

Quick Fact: Alloy rims without decorative chrome finishes tend to resist rust better than cheaper coated versions.

Taking Care of Your Tires in Winter

For every Canadian vehicle owner, winter tires are an important investment – not only financially, but for safety as well. Winter tires are only as good as their condition, so taking care of them should be a priority.

To get the most out of them:

• Clean rims regularly to remove salt and grime buildup.
• Check tire pressure monthly—especially after temperature drops.
• Store off-season tires properly in a cool, dry place.
• Schedule balancing and alignment at least once per season.

The mechanics at Park Muffler can help you keep your winter tires in excellent condition by offering professional servicing, repair and installation.

Contact us today for more information about proper tire care!

–

Written: November 15, 2019 | Last Updated: November 5, 2025 | By Park Muffler